2020 NFL Draft 5 Years Later

With the 2025 NFL draft just around the corner it's time to take a look at the draft that occurred 5 years ago.  We are going to look at it a few different ways but it's always fun to pick out a few teams and focus on them.  

Let's start by looking at the Dallas Cowboys.  PFF gave the Dallas Cowboys an A+ on their draft that year.  If you look a their picks of consensus top 200 talent from that draft class they earned 178 points in value.  This is according to https://jacklich10.com/bigboard/nfl/.  That is top of the class.  If you look at Pro Football Reference data they averaged 17.75 value points per player they drafted, which is an A according to my grading scale, with their 7 picks and a total of 124.23 points for their team from that draft which is a B.  They had three big hits WR CeeDee Lamb, CB Trevon Diggs and C Tyler Biadasz.  Biadasz was one guy who was considered a high value pick in the draft, he was a consensus top 100 pick that they got at 146. Then they did it again with edge Bradlee Anae at 179.  Anae would not have much of a career.  He had tested poorly in the combine and that was credited with his slip back in the draft.  Still taking someone who was a consensus top 100 player in the 5th round is sound drafting and got them good draft grades.  Dallas is an odd team.  The person in charge of their drafting, Will McClay, is considered to be one of the best in the NFL and a reason why the Cowboys have been able to stay competitive despite having an owner who spends some of the least amount of cash on his roster.  

The Cincinnati Bengals got an A from PFF on their post draft score and that is reflected in that they got 147 points of value with their picks.  All 7 of their picks were considered top 200 talents and that is something that really impresses the draft analyzers.  In terms of how impactful the draft was for the team, well they have gained 152.51 points for their team over the last 5 years from that draft.  That's the second highest of any team and they averaged 21.79 value points per player they drafted which is number 1.  Out of 7 picks they also had three big hits, QB Joe Burrow, WR Tee Higgins, and LB Logan Wilson.  The good thing is all 7 of their picks contributed, all 7 of their picks only played for Cincinnati, and all but one were still in the NFL in 2024.    Only 4 of Dallas's picks were still in the NFL in 2024 and only 2 of those were still with Dallas in 2024.  The Bengals poor drafting has been designated as their biggest problem in 2024, but in 2020 it was their drafting that helped to setup their run to the Super Bowl.  The Bengals are taking the position that it was not their drafting but their coaching on defense that failed to develop players.  It will be interesting to see how things fare for them in 2025.  

Here we have to talk about the Minnesota Vikings.  They had 15 picks in 2020 and lead all teams in total points added to their team from this draft at 160.59.  They also had 101 value points vs consensus in their top 200 consensus player picks.  This draft netted them a B from PFF and I'm not surprised since they took some wild swings with many of their later picks in the draft.  Still they have gotten consistent play out of many of their picks though their first round was a bit of a hit/miss.  WR Justin Jefferson has given them 57 points of value he was pick number 22 in the draft.  They also had a second 1st round pick and they took CB Jeff Gladney.  Gladney played for the Vikings in his first season starting the majority of games, but was released after the season for domestic violence and then later died in a car crash, never playing again in the NFL.  In the 5th and 6th rounds the Vikings gook WR KJ Osborn, T Blake Brandel, and S Josh Metellus.  All are still with the Vikings and have combined for just over 38 value points added to the Vikings.  Just goes to show that if you have 15 picks in a draft there is a good chance you can add real value to your team.  

Of course that isn't always the case look at the Jacksonville Jaguars.  Their 2020 draft was a complete mess.  PFF gave their draft an A, but by my analysis their post draft score should have been a C only getting 8 points of value from the top 200 talent they drafted with their 12 picks.  From those 12 picks they have only garnered 64.64 value points over these last five years and only averaged 5.39 value points per draft pick with the players they selected.  They also had two first round picks.  CB CJ Henderson, number 9 pick, contributed 4 points to the Jaguars and 12 points total to the NFL.  He was no longer in the NFL in 2024.  DE K'Lavon Chaisson, taken 20th overall, contributed 7 points of value to the Jaguars and only 10 points to the NFL as a whole.  Still 12 picks lands them a C grade when it comes to team value gained from the draft, so not the worst.  

The worst was the Tennessee Titans who only gained a total of 20.2 point from their 6 picks in the 2020 draft and only averaged 3.37 career value points per draft pick.  Only 2 of these players were still in the NFL in 2024 and none were playing for Tennessee.  The biggest bust was their first round pick T Isaiah Wilson who they took 21 spots ahead of consensus.  He never played in the NFL showing no interest in playing after being drafted.  One issue as well was that with their final 2 picks they took some swings which both failed.  One was for a QB Cole McDonald who never played in the NFL.  The other was for S Chris Jackson who they took 282 spots ahead of consensus and who played 3 years and only provided them with 2 points of value.  That really only gave them 4 picks of consensus top 200 players and none of them did much and two of those players they took well ahead of consensus.  

Here are screen shots of the data. The grades are my grades based on the numbers.  

Here are the teams ranked by Total Value Added to Their Team 

Here are the teams ranked by Average Career Value Per Pick  

Here are the teams ranked by Value Added from Consensus Top 200 Picks 

Finally here are the teams listed alphabetically

KEY:  

Tscore: is the total value added to the team from the draft

TTScore: is the total value added to the NFL from the draft

ATScore:  is the total value added to the team - (total value added to the NFL - total value added to the team). This score can be helpful to see if teams are making the most out of their draft picks.  

VPP:  Average value added to NFL per player from the draft

T200total:  Consensus value added from top 200 consensus picks

RawTotal:  Consensus value added from all picks based on consensus

Note on consensus data not all players were in the consensus data I used.  This is one reason why I focused specifically on top 200 consensus players.  Research has shown that the top 200 consensus players ranking out performs NFL teams over time.