Thursday, April 28, 2011

NFL draft, Thursday

So if I was Canton, Ohio, I would rebuild the whole town around the Pro Football Hall of Fame. I would construct 32 definable neighborhoods--one for each NFL team. Only verifiable fans or former players or coaches of that team would be allowed to move in to its district, and each district would have a small football stadium (or not so small; I'm flexible) constructed as an exact replica of its team's actual stadium or one of its former stadia (again, flexible).

NFL draft weekend would be the biggest deal of the year in my Canton.

Every team would have to confidentially register a complete list of all the prospects it might draft or sign as free agents after the draft, and all of those players would come to Canton for the weekend.

Furthermore, each team--all of its coaches and no fewer than 44 but no more than 88 players--would move in to its district for the week. Maybe the players would spread out into the guest bedrooms of their fans' houses. Or maybe their team would have a big dorm.

Tonight would start intra-squad scrimmages at each of the 32 team stadia around Canton. The Dolphins, for example, would have the first Aqua-vs.-Orange game (of four or five, maybe, of the weekend) at its Little Orange Bowl in the heart of Canton's Miami neighborhood. These would be coached by the actual staffs of the teams, and they would go on continuously throughout all seven rounds of the draft.

At the stadium next door to the Hall of Fame would commence a series of all-star games among all of the registered prospects. These games would be coached by two staffs comprised mostly of Super Bowl-winning teams. Tonight's first game, for example, might be coached by the surviving staff members of the 1974-75 Pittsburgh Steelers and the 1969-70 Kansas City Chiefs. These staffs would be augmented, as necessary, by former players of the team. (Len Dawson might take the place of dead '69-70 Chiefs head coach Hank Stram, while Joe Greene could sub for passed '74-75 Steelers defensive coordinator Bud Carson.)

Roger Goodell, Gene Washington, Mike Tirico, Mel Kiper, Corey Chavous, etc. would all be up in the booth, announcing picks and providing analysis over the P.A. system and TV. Down in the stands would be all of the personnel staffs of the 32 teams. As word of a selection is sent from the stands and to the booth, the chosen prospect would then by helicoptered directly to the intrasquad scrimmage of his new team. If that team already has 88 players, it would immediately have to cut a player to make room for the draft choice.

This goes on all weekend, with all sorts of interesting TV coverage addressing questions such as what fourth-year backup linebacker on the Falcons' roster is in jeopardy of losing his job with the arrival of Atlanta's third-round draft choice just a few seconds ago. Plus, in this weekend, NFL.com would release a huge batch of commissioned white papers with titles such as Good Selections That Didn't Work Out and Why; Back to the West Texas A&M Running Back Well: The Mercury Morris, Duane Thomas and Rocky Thompson Picks in 1969, '70 and '71, and Chuck Fairbanks's 1974 Draft Board.

Also throughout the weekend would go on open, global balloting for that year's Hall of Fame class. There would be four, maybe eight selections from the field of 32 seeded by the team-by-team nominating conventions that had taken place in the team's districts earlier in the week.

On Sunday afternoon and evening, following Saturday's draft conclusion, there would be a grand closing ceremony featuring marching bands and Up With People. The Hall of Fame class would be announced, as would the signings of free agents (both undrafted rookies and veteran cast-offs from other clubs). The players who failed to make an NFL roster would then be assigned to teams based in former NFL towns (Louisville, Evansville, Los Angeles, etc.) for a spring minor league. Everything would end happily for everyone.




I will entertain questions, comments and proposals as I watch the real draft, off and on this weekend.

9 comments:

  1. This sounds like a beautiful dream. And I really like the picture.

    Eric, who do you trust: Mel Kiper or Todd McShay?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Eric, who do you use for the draft: ESPN or the NFL Network?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you, GoHeath. Well, this is first year I've had NFL Network at my disposal in the house, so I'm an ESPN guy. But I am interested in checking out NFL Network over the course of the weekend.

    I'm getting to tune in to the first round only now, as we had a bunch of people over to the house for dinner. I'm thrilled with the Dolphins' first-round selection of Mike Pouncey, an interior offensive lineman from Florida who appears to be about as safe a choice as there is in this draft. Followers of my work in the NCFA know that I believe in continually building/improving a team from the football out ... you must always ensure you have quality in the interior lines first, then you move out to quarterback, offensive tackles, defensive ends or inside linebackers. Consequently, the choice of Pouncey aligns perfectly with my view of the world.

    I, of course, favor my old friend, Mel Kiper, over Todd McShay, but I must say that I think Kiper makes it incredibly hard on McShay, who seems knowledgeable and pleasant enough.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rob, if you made it this late, I would also be very pleased with the Steelers' choice.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Special (oh) Kentucky note: Five of the first six and 10 of the 32 first-round choices came from the Southeastern Conference (none from UK). Admittedly a newcomer to the conversation, I must say that I think this is the big difference between UK and its conference competition. Kentucky typically seems to have enough competent plodders to compete with the rest of the SEC; it's that they never seem to have nearly as many terrific players. In fact, they often have to manufacture them out of high-school misfits like Randall Cobb and Derrick Locke, and then they have to depend on their count-on-one-hand playmakers so heavily that those guys invariably get banged up over the course of the season.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Rob's Day 1 Steelers and Dolphins (mostly Steelers) analysis:

    "Miami got the guy I was hoping would fall to Pittsburgh. But it's clear now that Mike Pouncey was not going to fall that far. I think Maurkice Pouncey's year last year helped his brother's stock this year. At any rate, if Mike's even 75% as good his rookie year, Miami has a very good pick. My guess is this is Miami's best 1st round pick in several years. You know, there's some convential draft wisdom that you don't draft safeties, guards, or centers really high. I don't completely understand that. I mean, if a player's a top-level talent and a game changer, why not? Just with Pittsburgh, I think of Polamalu and Pouncey in the last 7 or 8 years. Granted, they weren't top-10 picks, but in retrospect, I'm sure there are many teams in the top 10 those years who would now trade their picks in for one of those 2.

    "... I ended up catching a little more than you did {of the first-round coverage}. I tuned in just before the Ravens botched their pick (they didn't get their pick in on time, and KC jumped in front of them).

    "While I was hoping for Pouncey going into the day, I have to say I was pleasantly surprised the Steelers got Ironhead's kid. So there's a solid Pittsburgh connection there. IRONHEAD! Ha. Pittsburgh has drafted pretty well in the first round going back at least to 2000. While a pick may not be who I'm pulling for at the time, their first round guys have done well:

    "2010 = Maurkice Pouncey
    2009 = Ziggy Hood
    2008 = Rashard Mendenhall
    2007 = Lawrence Timmons
    2006 = Santonio Holmes
    2005 = Heath Miller
    2004 = Ben Roethlisberger
    2003 = Troy Polamalu
    2002 = Kendall Simmons
    2001 = Casey Hampton
    2000 = Plaxico Burress

    "Every one of those guys with the exception of Hood has had at least one year in a Pro Bowl, or had one or more Pro Bowl worthy seasons. And Hood finally got significant starting time last season and seems to be getting better. Even Simmons, who has mostly been adequate, had a really good season or two.

    "Looking at that list, I can recall only 3 or 4 of them being the guy I was hoping they'd take at the time: Mendenhall, Roethlisberger, Polamalu, and maybe Miller.

    "To summarize: You should be very excited about Miami's pick. And also, IRONHEAD!"

    ReplyDelete
  7. As someone living in the DC area, I found that list of Steelers draft picks very poignant. Here are the Redskins' first-round picks over the same period:

    2010: Trent Williams
    2009: Brian Orakpo
    2008: NONE
    2007: LaRon Landry
    2006: NONE
    2005: Carlos Rogers and Jason Campbell
    2004: Sean Taylor
    2003: NONE
    2002: Patrick Ramsey
    2001: Rod Gardner
    2000: LaVar Arrington and Chris Samuels

    Not quite Pittsburgh quality. Although LaVar has a really good radio show these days.

    ReplyDelete